MoC 2026.
- Impressions -

October 2026.




I had the great pleasure of taking part in MoC 7, 2026 (Models of Consciousness). October 15-16, 2026.

Tried to follow as much as possible, But, well, these notes are, of course, in no way, shape or form complete...
Below you will find impressions from the conference, and links for further reading.

     Generated by Gemini 2.5 Flash Image
     Generated by ''Gemini 2.5 Flash Image''.
Disclaimer

Moc7.
Hans Christian Ørsted Institute, University of Copenhagen [1].


Moc7.

Moc7.
Hans Christian Ørsted Institute, University of Copenhagen [1].
The building is a prominent example of Danish postwar modernism and brutalist institutional architecture.

Thursday.
October 15th.



Moc7. Copenhagen. October 2026.
Mirja Hartimo talked about: ''Husserls philosophy of mathematics and logic''.
That is:
Husserls views on mathematics and logic evolved over time.
From an early ''Platonist'' phase around 1900, where he believed mathematical structures were eternal and independent of human thought, towards the 1920s, where he viewed mathematics more as a social practice that connects to an objective reality.

Moc7. Copenhagen. October 2026.
Transcendental phenomenology.

''Transcendental Phenomenology'', according to Wikipedia:
Transcendental phenomenology is the study of the essential structures that are left in pure consciousness [2].
''Transcendental'' means it searches for the hidden rules and conditions within our consciousness that make any kind of knowledge, logic, or objective truth possible in the first place.
''Phenomenology'' means it is a purely descriptive study of experiences and phenomena.

(Notice) Compare with Buddhism that argues that no object (form) has a fixed, independent, permanent essence. Form is ''empty'' because it relies entirely on a web of causes, conditions, and mental labels.
I.e. similarly, here it is argued that we should stop assuming things exist ''out there'' on their own, but instead focus more on how our consciousness builds meaning (Constructing the world we see from vague inputs).

Mind The Substrate.
October 15th.

Mind The Substrate.
On Substrate Dependence and Organisational Invariance. AI, LLMs, and consciousness.


Moc7. Copenhagen. October 2026.
According to Chalmers:
Principle of organizational invariance, holding that given any system that has conscious experiences, then any system that has the same fine-grained functional organization will have qualitatively identical experiences.
...
Whether the organization is realized in silicon chips, in the population of China, or in beer cans and ping-pong balls does not matter. As long as the functional organization is right, conscious experience will be determined.
I.e. David Chalmers argues that consciousness only depends on a system's structure and organization, regardless of whether it is made of brain cells or silicon chips.
However, here, the author, Julian Braunwarth, criticizes this idea by pointing out that physical laws change fundamentally when you scale things up or down in space and time. Therefore, changing the physical scale of a conscious process, even if you keep the same organization, might destroy the exact physical properties needed for consciousness to exist.

Moc7.Copenhagen. October 2026.
The ''Fading Qualia'' argument
(According to Chalmers):
  • The Thought Experiment: Imagine replacing the neurons in a conscious brain with silicon chips, one by one, until the whole brain is digital.
  • The ''Fading'' Idea: If you believe a robot cannot be conscious, then consciousness must slowly fade away and wash out during this replacement process.
  • The Problem: Because the silicon chips work exactly like neurons, the person's brain processing stays completely normal. This means they would have a fading consciousness but would not notice or report it.
  • The Conclusion: It is highly unlikely that your conscious experience could disappear without your brain processing noticing it. Therefore, Chalmers argues that consciousness must remain completely vivid throughout the entire replacement.

Moc7. Copenhagen. October 2026.
Hans Christian Ørsted Institute, University of Copenhagen [1].

Discussion sessions.
October 15th.

Group discussions about what ''consciousness is''...
Followed by exercises, and more discussion: What concrete deliverables can consciousness science give us?
Finally, group presentations. And, perhaps, a roadmap to create a shared, collective synthesis.

Moc7.
Hans Christian Ørsted Institute, University of Copenhagen [1].


Rather surprisingly, to me, our group decided to focus on ''collective consciousness''.

At first, I thought we were going to discuss how different areas of the brain work together to create consciousness. But no. Instead, the topic turned out to be inspired by the Singing Revolution [2] across Estonia, Latvia, and Lithuania, which symbolized unity and public commitment. This led to a debate about whether the Baltic singing groups (as a whole) were actually conscious, or if we were simply looking at how crowds work together, bond and experience mutual solidarity.

Moc7. Copenhagen. October 2026.
Discussions.

Moc7.Copenhagen. October 2026.
As the discussions proceeded, more and more blackboards were covered in a clutter of notes that became increasingly difficult to decipher.
At the end of the sessions, two ''volunteers'' from our group were appointed to make sense of it all and present our findings to the other groups.
Not an easy task...

Theories of Consciousness.

Many theories attempt to explain consciousness...
Below, illustrations of a number of these theories of consciousness
(Illustrations generated October 15th (late night).
With a little help from ''Gemini 2.5 Flash''.



Generated by Gemini 2.5 Flash Image
Generated by ''Gemini 2.5 Flash Image''.
[3], [4]
Generated by Gemini 2.5 Flash Image
Generated by ''Gemini 2.5 Flash Image''.
Panpsychism and Universal Mind theories [5], [6]

Generated by Gemini 2.5 Flash Image
Generated by ''Gemini 2.5 Flash Image''.
Simulation hypothesis [7].

Generated by Gemini 2.5 Flash Image
Generated by ''Gemini 2.5 Flash Image''.
Spirit worlds [8].
Ijcai 2018

October 15th.
Impressions.



Moc7. Copenhagen. October 2026.
Student-targeted flyers and community advertisements.

Moc7. Copenhagen. October 2026.
Community advertisements.

Moc7. Copenhagen. October 2026.
Student-targeted flyers. Festival: ''3 days against the ruling ideas''.

Moc7. Copenhagen. October 2026.
Cafe. Jagtvej, Cph. ''No laptops''.

Moc7.Copenhagen. October 2026.
Cafe. Jagtvej, Cph.

Meeting Ameca. August 2024.
Asimovs robot laws.

       Ishiguro 2008

Moc7.
Hans Christian Ørsted Institute, University of Copenhagen [1].

October 15th.
Afternoon.

Indicators of AI Consciousness.

Moc7. Copenhagen. October 2026.
Modeling the Ghost in the Machine.
Testing whether AI has real feelings or subjective experiences is currently impossible.
...
these inner feelings are either hidden from science or completely non-physical.
Because we cannot measure this inner life through behaviors or computer code, researchers trying to build or test conscious AI are chasing an invisible ghost.

Moc7. Copenhagen. October 2026.
Tobias Schlicht: All possible markers of consciousness are either absent, ambiguous, or question-begging in AI.
  • First Person data are absent in AI.
  • Neural markers are absent in AI.
  • Behavioral markers are ambiguous (consider LLM outputs).


Moc7. Copenhagen. October 2026.
Angela Johnson. Northeastern University. ''Biology-Inspired AI Agent Design''. And tracking Metastability, Recurrence, and Ignition in an Agents Attention Stream.
This framework tracks how an AI agent manages its memory and attention over time
...
Instead of looking for real feelings, it measures how well the AI integrates information, adapts to changes, or struggles with mental collapse. This makes it easier to test and understand how complex AI systems think and behave.

In the human brain, the neocortex is responsible for higher-order functions like language, abstract thinking, reasoning, and processing sensory information. An LLM plays an analogous role. It handles the ''thinking'', language generation, pattern recognition, and semantic understanding. But on its own it has no persistent state, no drives, and no memory between calls.


Moc7. Copenhagen. October 2026.
Dezhi Luo: Testing whether AI is conscious is hard because we cannot truly prove an AI has real inner experiences. But Instead of looking for absolute truth, we can use practical tests based on computer code to check how close AI is to human thinking...
A ''Jacobian lens'' (J-lens) is an AI research tool created by the AI firm Anthropic [9].
The ''Jacobian lens'' translates hidden patterns inside an LLM model back into readable human words, revealing what the AI is about to say or considering. I.e. it reads ''thoughts'' the AI model never actually says out loud.

By looking through this lens, a hidden internal workspace was discovered. This space acts like a human's ''working memory'' or a conscious scratchpad where the AI balances strategies, handles multi-step logic, and figures out complex reasoning before making its next move.

Very much like Global Workspace Theory [10] states that the human brain processes most data unconsciously in the background, but brings critical information into a centralized "workspace" (the spotlight on stage) to share with the rest of the brain.

Moving on, video AI models can understand the physical world using pictures and videos instead of text words. This lets them visualize 3D objects from different angles, move through spaces, and learn basic physics like gravity, depth, and how hidden objects still exist.
Video Generation Models (VGMs):
  • Native Visual Thinking: The AI operates directly within the visual space. It does not need to translate concepts into text tokens to process them.
  • Spatial Awareness: The model can perform mental rotations and navigation. It understands how a 3D object looks from different angles and how environments change as a camera moves.
  • Internal World Model: Eventually developind an internal model of physics. Including understanding gravity, depth, and object permanence (knowing a ball still exists when it rolls behind a couch).

October 15th.
Afternoon.

Niels Bohr institute.

Niels Bohr Institute. Copenhagen. October 2026.
Niels Bohr Institute.

Niels Bohr Institute. Copenhagen. October 2026.
Niels Bohr Institute.

Train trip. Denmark.
The Niels Bohr Institute. Denmark.
Shown: The NBI Colliderscope. A permanent light-artwork installed on the exterior of the institute's main building. Directly connected to the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) at CERN, displaying real-time or translated visual data from particle collision experiments.

         Ijcai 2018. Stockholm.

      Ijcai 2018. Stockholm.    Ijcai 2018. Stockholm.

October 16th.




Moc7. Copenhagen. October 2026.
Självet. Got a pamphlet at the conference (near the registration desk) about the creation of the self.

Moc7. Copenhagen. October 2026.
Självet. Pamphlet.

The pamphlet specifically highlights how the ''self'' is not a static object but an active process of self-creation.
Human beings are not born with self-awareness, but research suggests it develops by around 18 months of age.
...
there is still no knowledge about how infants actually become self-aware [11].

Generative Neurophenomenology.
October 16th.

Guillaume Dumas talked about ''Formalizing Generative Neurophenomenology''.
From Coupled Brains to Metacognitive Agents.

Moc7. Copenhagen. October 2026.

Moc7. Copenhagen. October 2026.
Most consciousness studies only focus on one brain at a single moment, ignoring how our experiences change over time and during social interactions. Here, ''generative neurophenomenology'' looks at how our feelings connect with a) our biology, b) other people, and c) our surroundings.
I.e. according to Evan Thompson and Francisco J. Varela we shouldn't think of the mind as a computer trapped inside a skull... [12].
Instead:
Consciousness does not just happen in the brain. Instead, our mind is actively created through three continuous loops or ''cycles''.
  • (The Body): The constant loop between your brain and your physical body (like feeling a heartbeat, hunger, or physical comfort).
  • (The World): The loop between you and your physical environment (like looking at an object, moving toward it, and touching it).
  • (Other People): The loop between you and other humans (like talking, reading body language, and understanding what someone else is feeling).
In short: Your mind is actively shaped by the cooperation between your brain, your physical body, and the world around you.


In ''Now is the time: operationalizing generative neurophenomenology through interpersonal methods"'' [13]
Anne Monnier, Lena Adel, and Guillaume Dumas describe three types of experiences useful when we study lived experience:
  • First-person experience: Subjective, internal conscious experience (thinking, feeling, and sensing).
  • Second-person experience (intersubjective/social): One's relationship to the other, capturing social interactions, participatory sense-making, and intersubjectivity.
  • Third-person objective data: Classical neurobehavioral and physiological measurements, such as multimodal multi-brain and multi-body interpersonal synchrony.
With the main take-away being that through subjective experiences, social interactions, and objective biological we can better understand how humans experience the world together.


  • Your experience of life never stands still; it flows constantly. You cannot understand an experience by just looking at a ''snapshot'' of a single moment, because it is always unfolding over a lifetime.
  • You do not experience the world in isolation. Other people are actively co-creating and shaping your experience right now in the present moment of interaction.
  • Your experiences and ways of understanding the world are inherited from the past. Meaning, culture, language, and everyday practices are passed down (transmitted) across lives and generations.
I.e. human experience is always a) in constant motion, b) it is shaped together with others in the present, and c) is deeply colored by the culture and history we have inherited.



Moc7. Copenhagen. October 2026.

                Robot Index

Onwards 2024       Onwards 2025      Onwards 2026

    Conference selfie. Notice: This image is NOT real. Generated by Gemini 2.5 Flash Image.
    Conference selfie artificially generated by
    ''Gemini Flash Image generator''.

Conscious awareness is valenced.
October 16th.

Medha Shekhar talked about ''Conscious awareness is necessarily valenced''.

Moc7. Copenhagen. October 2026.
Conscious perception is valenced.
Our minds automatically label conscious experiences as pleasant or unpleasant.
...
That is, brain process automatically gives an emotional value to everything we consciously notice.
For more about consciousness and feelings, see also: ''The Hidden Spring. A journey to the Source of Consciousness'' by Mark Solms [14].

Moc7. Copenhagen. October 2026.
Why do we have conscious experiences?
Reinforcement learning paradigms assume that rewards originate in the environment. And largely neglect self-defined or intrinsic goals.

With consciousness:

Moc7. Copenhagen. October 2026.

October 16th.
Posters.



Moc7. Copenhagen. October 2026.
Poster by Michael Bennett: ''Timelines. Living things are attracted to what lets them persist''...

To survive in a changing world, living things must be able to distinguish between what keeps them alive and what kills them.
Bennett calls this the most fundamental element of consciousness: The feeling that something is inherently good or bad.

Moc7. Copenhagen. October 2026.
Poster by Luna Wang: ''Extended consciousness thesis: A subject's conscious experience is partly constituted by vehicles outside of their brain, including the subject's body and environment (also known as vehicle externalism about consciousness).
(This is) An invitation to an open conversation: What can the extended consciousness debate reveal about the assumptions of contemporary models of consciousness regarding the boundaries of the system that realises experience
''.

Moc7. Copenhagen. October 2026.

Moc7. Copenhagen. October 2026.
H.C. Ørsted Institute, University of Copenhagen [1].

Moc7. Copenhagen. October 2026.

October 16th.

Developmental Routes to Consciousness.


Moc7. Copenhagen. October 2026.
H.C. Ørsted Institute, University of Copenhagen [1].
Moc7. Copenhagen. October 2026.

Moc7. Copenhagen. October 2026.
Fernando Rodriguez: The Church-Turing thesis suggests that all thinking can be broken down into computer code.

But, still, human consciousness and agency exceeds what computers can do...

Moc7. Copenhagen. October 2026.
The diagram on the right shows Bittorio, a classic computer-simulated entity (a ring of binary cells) created by philosopher Francisco Varela. It demonstrates how a simple system can interact with its environment and create its own ''meaning''. even though it lacks any real consciousness or inner experience.

Moc7. Copenhagen. October 2026.
The artwork on the right depicts a fractal, a mathematical pattern that repeats itself infinitely at different scales. Because fractals are highly prominent in nature (like in snowflakes, coastlines, or ferns), the presenter uses this image to show that nature natively uses computational, geometric rules to organize itself out of chaos.


I.e. it is here argued that computation isn't just an artificial thing humans invented in silicon chips. Instead, computation is a natural phenomenon that biology uses to generate life and mind.
Living things (life) and thinking minds (cognition) can only exist, because the universe has a foundational baseline of structure or order.

Moc7. Copenhagen. October 2026.
Nadia Khan. Dream LLMs, A Computational Framework for Quantifying the Human Subconscious.

Moc7. Copenhagen. October 2026.

Dream LLMs use artificial intelligence to quickly analyze thousands of written dream reports for hidden patterns and emotions. By turning dreams into searchable data, this tool helps scientists study the human subconscious much faster than traditional psychological methods. Ultimately, it could reveal common mental structures shared by people all over the world.
Moc7. Copenhagen. October 2026.
Selfie. October 16th.

October 16th.

The Niels Bohr building.

Moc7. Copenhagen. October 2026.
Niels Bohr building [15]. University of Copenhagen.

Moc7. Copenhagen. October 2026.
Niels Bohr building [15].

Moc7. Copenhagen. October 2026.
Niels Bohr building [15]. University of Copenhagen.

Moc7. Copenhagen. October 2026.
Niels Bohr building [15]. University of Copenhagen.

Moc7. Copenhagen. October 2026.
Nordic roots.
Nordic Lunch. Niels Bohr building [15]. University of Copenhagen.

October 16th.

Harald Atmanspacher keynote.

Moc7. Copenhagen. October 2026.
Margrethe Bohr auditorium (Wife of Niels Bohr). Niels Bohr building [15]. University of Copenhagen.

Moc7. Copenhagen. October 2026.
From Harald Atmanspachers keynote:
''Dual-Aspect Monism''. A reaction to Descartes interactive dualism that avoids both physicalist and idealist leanings. Sees physical and mental as dual aspects of one common ground.

Moc7. Copenhagen. October 2026.
Margrethe Bohr auditorium (Wife of Niels Bohr). Niels Bohr building [15]. University of Copenhagen.

A common ground we can't really see...

The ''Great Smoky Dragon'' is a famous metaphor introduced by the American theoretical physicist John Archibald Wheeler in the 1970s to illustrate the mind-bending nature of quantum mechanics.


Moc7. Copenhagen. October 2026.
John Wheelers ''Smoky Dragon''

Harald Atmanspacher about ''matter is less and less material'':
Psychologists make psychology increasingly dependent on physiology and external observation, and tend to think of matter as something much more solid and indubitable than mind. Meanwhile the physicists ... have been making matter less and less material. ... Whoever reads, for example, Professor Eddington's ''Space, Time, and Gravitation'', will see that an old-fashioned materialism can receive no support from modern physics.

Harald Atmanspacher, about an unpartitioned base, the ''unus mundus''.
Psychophysically neutral domain without distinctions such as mind-matter, subject-object, self-world, with an entirely unpartitioned base level (unus mundus)
Aerchetypal patterns provide a hierarchy of psychophysically neutral order elements between unus mundus and mental/physical aspects.

Moc7. Copenhagen. October 2026.
Margrethe Bohr auditorium (Wife of Niels Bohr). Niels Bohr building [15]. University of Copenhagen.

Kurt Gödel (Letter October 6, 1961).
The idea that everything in the world has a meaning is an exact analogue of the principle that everything has a cause, on which rests all of science.
By quoting Gödel, Atmanspacher indicates that just as physical science is built on the assumption that everything has a physical cause, a complete science of consciousness must recognize that everything in the universe also holds a relational meaning.

Moc7. Copenhagen. October 2026.
Margrethe Bohr auditorium (Wife of Niels Bohr). Niels Bohr building [15]. University of Copenhagen.
Normally, science relies entirely on physical cause-and-effect (causality) to explain how things interact. In this talk, it was assumed/argued that the mental world and the material world do not directly cause one another. Instead, they are linked by meaning.

Moc7. Copenhagen. October 2026.
Margrethe Bohr auditorium (Wife of Niels Bohr). Niels Bohr building [15]. University of Copenhagen.
In the book, ''Dual-Aspect Monism and the Deep Structure of Meaning'', there is more about the historical roots of the theory, pioneered by physicist Wolfgang Pauli and psychologist Carl Jung, which uses meaning as a natural law.


As the conference came to an end, leaving me with countless impressions and ready to relax a little, I returned to my hotel, where I found the cleaning robot still busy vacuuming, seemingly enjoying itself.
Hotel Vacuum Cleaner.
Hotel Vacuum Cleaner.

Making sense of it all.

''A World Appears''.
So, what is consciousness really?

Below, a (small) review of Michael Pollans great book ''A World Appears: A Journey into Consciousness''.
Great because it provides a good overview of where ''consciousness research'' actually stands in 2026.
Which makes a review of this book a fitting way to conclude the ''consciousness investigations'' on this page (see above).

Pollan quotes William James (The Principles of Psychology, 1890) [16].
A good third of our psychic life consists in these rapid premonitory perspective views of schemes of thought not yet articulate.
I.e. a massive part of our mental life exists in a ''halo'' of consciousness. Where we know exactly what we mean or what we are about to say before we have actually found the words to express it. That wordless understanding is what James refers to as a ''scheme of thought not yet articulate''.

Pollan then, interestingly, concludes:
If James’s account rings true, if it chimes with our lived experience, then how could we ever accept the idea that consciousness is reducible to information, to computable bits or pixels? How could the concept of information ever capture or convey something like the aura or halo of a thought, or its familiarity, or the ''fringe of unarticulated affinities'' linking two thoughts, or the afterglow of a thought and its coloring of the thought to come? What sort of hardware, neuronal or silicon-based could do that?
Well, indeed, the jury is still out on what consciousness really is...

The upper brainstem might be a place to look, according to neuroscientist Antonio Damasio:
Damasio pointed out that damage to the cortex has remarkably little effect on consciousness, while small lesions in structures of the upper brainstem that monitor interoceptive signals—information about the body—will shut down consciousness completely. Neurons linked to these structures reach deep into the body, where they gather vital information about how things are going.
Still, what is the purpose of ''thinking'', and consciousness in particular?
According to neuroscientist Karl Friston it is all about ''minimizing surprise'':
In Fristons view, the great drive common to all living things, whether at the level of the cell, the organ, or the organism, is to minimize surprise. the ever-present threat to homeostasis and therefore to the systems continued existence. ''How do systems minimise expected surprises, in practice?''. Friston writes. By ''avoid[ing] possible surprises in the future (such as being cold, hungry or dead)''.
Which raises the question: Could there be some sort of ''minimal consciousness'' that we all have? Including animals and babies?
Pollan writes:
This kind of minimal consciousness is part of the phenomenology of both babies and animals. This state, I realized, is as close as we can get, as humans, to experiencing the simple animal sentience that precedes full-blown consciousness.
Ok, well, but do all agree that consciousness is a physical thing?
Kastrups [17] argument for rejecting physicalism goes like this: Everything we know about reality we know because of experience, either our personal experience of the world or the collective experience of reality we call science. (He’s not saying there isn’t a real world out there, just that we know it only by way of consciousness). ''Matter is an inference'', Kastrup contends, ''and mind a given''.
Again, so what is consciousness really?...

In the final part of the book Pollan describes how he has an experience of becoming ''more'' conscious not by overthinking the past or the future, but by quietening his mind and anchoring himself fully in the present moment.
When the self is deprived of time past (memory) and future (anticipation), it melts away. Absorbed in meditation, or in my chores, I could feel my time horizon shrink.
An awesome book indeed.

Trip impressions.

October 15-16.

Copenhagen. October 2026.
Copenhagen.

Copenhagen. October 2026.
Copenhagen.

Copenhagen. October 2026.
Kgs. Nytorv. Copenhagen.

Copenhagen. October 2026.
Pho.

Copenhagen. October 2026.
Pho. Copenhagen.

Copenhagen. October 2026.
Copenhagen.

Copenhagen. October 2026.
Rosenborggade. Copenhagen.

Copenhagen. October 2026.

Copenhagen. October 2026.
Copenhagen. Center.

Copenhagen. October 2026.
Copenhagen.

Copenhagen. October 2026.
Copenhagen. Tea.

Copenhagen. October 2026.
Copenhagen. Center.

Copenhagen. October 2026.
Copenhagen.

                Asimovs robot laws.

                 Humanoids 2024. Nancy France.

            Top 10 reasons people dont like robots.

More Impressions.

Sightseeing with the help of an AI image generator.
Based on a hotel sightseing pamphlet, ''Image generator'' was asked to make a sightseeing tour for me (So, I could just stay home, and work, instead of chasing tourist sites):

Sightseeing. Generated by Gemini 2.5 Flash Image.
Sightseeing tour according to the ''Gemini Flash Image generator''.

Sightseeing.Generated by Gemini 2.5 Flash Image.
Sightseeing tour according to the ''Gemini Flash Image generator''.
Sightseeing. Generated by Gemini 2.5 Flash Image.
Sightseeing tour according to the
''Gemini Flash Image generator''.

Impressions.

October, 17th.



Copenhagen. October 2026.
Copenhagen. Center.

Copenhagen. October 2026.
Copenhagen. Central Railway Station.

Train trip. Denmark.
Going home.
Train trip. Denmark.

   MlPrague 2019    MlPrague 2021    MlPrague 2022    MlPrague 2023    MlPrague 2024    MlPrague 2025